What’s
the Best Way to Teach Grammar?
There are several “schools” of
thought on how grammar should be taught.
If you want to start an argument in a
teachers’ lounge, just bring up the topic!
Traditionalists believe that drilling the
basics by diagramming sentences is the only way to truly learn
the fundamentals. They frequently replace actual writing with
grammar drills, reasoning that the drills are necessary to
prepare students to write eventually.
At the opposite end of the debate are
teachers who claim that grammar is learned by writing and
doesn’t have to be taught. Teachers on the
write-to-learn-grammar side believe that students who are only
taught the rules might pass tests, but can’t apply the rules
when they write.
Tools not Rules advocates a different
approach – a complete integration of grammar instruction and
writing – so young writers see grammar as a tool that writers
use, not a set of rules to be memorized.